Ideatax
HomeTeamOur ServicesPublicationsContact Us
Masa Depan Pajak Global: Membaca Agenda UNFCITC

The Future of Global Taxation: Understanding the UNFCITC Agenda

KUP

19 Nov 2026, 10.12 WIB

From August 3 to 13, 2026, the United Nations (UN) held the fifth session of the Intergovernmental Negotiating Committee (INC) to discuss the draft United Nations Framework Convention on International Tax Cooperation (UNFCITC) and its two early protocols.

 

The discussions covered several key issues, including the allocation of taxing rights, taxation of income from cross-border services, exchange of information, the prevention and resolution of tax disputes, and the relationship between the convention and existing international tax agreements. The draft under discussion remains at the zero draft stage, meaning it is an initial negotiating document that does not yet reflect an agreement among participating countries.

 

The UN aims to finalize the convention text and both protocols for submission to the UN General Assembly in 2027.

 

The establishment of the UNFCITC is linked to ongoing debates over global tax governance, which has largely been influenced by the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD). The OECD has developed various international standards to address cross-border tax avoidance. However, developing countries have also called for a greater role in shaping international tax standards and policies.

 

The Beginning of Global Tax Reform

 

Multinational enterprises can conduct business activities, generate income, and access markets across multiple jurisdictions without maintaining a significant physical presence in each country. This situation challenges the international tax system, particularly regarding Base Erosion and Profit Shifting (BEPS).

 

To address these challenges, the OECD, together with G20 countries, has developed various international tax reform initiatives, including the BEPS Action Plan and the Two-Pillar Solution. However, the formulation of these standards has also sparked debate over the representation of developing countries in decision-making.

 

Through UN General Assembly Resolution 77/244 of December 30, 2022, the UN initiated discussions on strengthening inclusive and effective international tax cooperation under its auspices.

 

The process continued with UN General Assembly Resolution 79/235 of December 24, 2024. This resolution adopted the Terms of Reference (ToR) for establishing the UNFCITC and formed the Intergovernmental Negotiating Committee to develop the convention and its two early protocols simultaneously.

 

The Global Tax Agenda

 

The UNFCITC is designed as a framework convention that will serve as the foundation for international tax cooperation. Under this approach, participating countries can agree on the convention's general principles, objectives, and commitments. More specific technical provisions can subsequently be developed through protocols.

 

The two early protocols under discussion cover the taxation of income from cross-border services in an increasingly digitalized and globalized economy, as well as the prevention and resolution of tax disputes.

 

The first protocol addresses the taxation of income derived from cross-border services. Under conventional tax systems, taxing rights are generally linked to physical presence or the existence of a permanent establishment (PE). However, technological developments enable service providers to generate income from a country without maintaining a significant physical presence there.

 

This protocol is expected to accommodate developments in such business models and clarify the allocation of taxing rights between source and residence countries.

 

The second protocol focuses on preventing and resolving tax disputes. Cross-border transactions can give rise to disputes because of differences in how tax treaties are interpreted, transfer pricing is determined, PE status is assessed, and income is allocated. Such disputes may arise between taxpayers and tax authorities or between jurisdictions.

 

Who Controls the Global Agenda?

 

The OECD has long been a leading institution in developing global tax standards. Through the BEPS Inclusive Framework, the OECD has expanded non-member countries' participation in discussions on international tax policy.

 

However, participation in a forum does not necessarily guarantee equal influence in decision-making. Developed countries generally have greater human resources, technical capabilities, and negotiation experience in formulating international tax standards. By contrast, many developing countries still face resource constraints that limit their ability to participate in negotiations and implement agreed standards.

 

As an organization with universal membership, the UN provides an intergovernmental negotiating forum in which all member states can participate in developing an international tax cooperation framework.

 

Even so, universal membership does not automatically guarantee equal influence. The success of the UNFCITC should be measured by its ability to accommodate the interests of countries with differing economic profiles and fiscal capacities, rather than merely by the number of participating countries.

 

The relationship between the UNFCITC and existing OECD instruments also requires attention. Coordination between the UN and the OECD is necessary to ensure that international tax standards remain consistent and complementary, without creating disproportionate administrative burdens.

 

Accordingly, the purpose of establishing the UNFCITC is not simply to shift the center of influence from the OECD to the UN. Its primary objective is to build a more representative and transparent international tax governance system that can balance the interests of source countries and residence countries.

 

Indonesia's Position at the Negotiating Table

 

As a developing country with a large domestic market and growing cross-border economic activity, Indonesia has a significant interest in the development of the UNFCITC.

 

First, Indonesia needs to advocate for a fairer allocation of taxing rights. Market locations, users, consumers, data, and economic activities should be considered when determining taxing rights over cross-border income.

 

International tax rules must adapt to evolving economic realities, including the role of market jurisdictions, where income is generated, and where economic value is created.

 

Second, Indonesia needs to closely scrutinize provisions governing the taxation of cross-border services. Clearer rules would reduce uncertainty in administering income tax, including Article 26 Withholding Tax (PPh Pasal 26) and the application of Double Taxation Agreements (DTAs).

 

Third, Indonesia must ensure that international dispute resolution mechanisms balance the protection of state revenue interests with legal certainty. Such mechanisms should strengthen the Mutual Agreement Procedure (MAP) without constraining national fiscal policy space through disproportionate additional obligations.

 

Fourth, Indonesia needs to strengthen its tax administration and diplomatic capacity. During the fifth INC session, Indonesia also emphasized the importance of technical assistance and capacity building to support the implementation of the convention.

 

Indonesia's Policy Challenges

 

The establishment of the UNFCITC still faces several challenges. Home countries of multinational enterprises tend to preserve taxing rights based on residence. Conversely, market and source countries seek an allocation of taxing rights that more accurately reflects where economic activity occurs.

 

Participating countries continue to debate the nexus factors used to determine taxing rights, the balance between source-based and residence-based taxation, and how the new provisions relate to existing international standards.

 

In response to these developments, Indonesia needs to prepare several policy measures.

 

First, the government must strengthen inter-agency coordination, particularly among the Ministry of Finance, the Directorate General of Taxes (DGT), the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, and diplomatic missions.

 

Second, Indonesia needs to assess the impact of the convention and its protocols on domestic tax regulations and existing DTAs. This assessment is necessary to identify potential policy changes and their implementation implications.

 

Third, Indonesia needs to build coalitions with developing countries that share similar interests. Such cooperation could strengthen Indonesia's bargaining position in the negotiation process.

 

Awaiting the Negotiation Outcomes

 

The UNFCITC is an initiative to reform international tax governance, aimed at expanding cooperation and improving the distribution of taxing rights among countries.

 

The success of this convention should be measured by its ability to improve the allocation of taxing rights, enhance the effectiveness of administrative cooperation, provide legal certainty, and support domestic resource mobilization.

 

For Indonesia, the UNFCITC negotiation process presents an opportunity to strengthen its position as both a source country and a market country in the global economy. To this end, Indonesia needs to actively advocate for its national interests, strengthen its negotiating capacity, and ensure that the agreed provisions can be implemented without undermining national fiscal policy space.

 

Global tax governance reform should result in a fairer distribution of economic benefits across countries while maintaining legal certainty and each country's fiscal sovereignty. The UNFCITC could serve as an instrument to achieve these objectives if it delivers substantive, implementable agreements.

 

References

  • Charter of the United Nations, 1945.
  • United Nations General Assembly Resolution A/RES/77/244 of December 30, 2022, on Promotion of Inclusive and Effective International Tax Cooperation at the United Nations.
  • United Nations General Assembly Resolution A/RES/78/230 of December 22, 2023, on Promotion of Inclusive and Effective International Tax Cooperation at the United Nations.
  • United Nations General Assembly Resolution A/RES/79/235 of December 24, 2024, on Promotion of Inclusive and Effective International Tax Cooperation at the United Nations.
  • United Nations General Assembly Resolution A/RES/80/128 of December 15, 2025, on Promotion of Inclusive and Effective International Tax Cooperation at the United Nations.
  • United Nations Document A/AC.298/2, Terms of Reference for a United Nations Framework Convention on International Tax Cooperation, dated January 16, 2025.
  • United Nations Document A/79/333, Report of the Second Session of the Ad Hoc Committee to Draft Terms of Reference for a United Nations Framework Convention on International Tax Cooperation.
  • United Nations Document A/AC.298, Intergovernmental Negotiating Committee on the United Nations Framework Convention on International Tax Cooperation, including the draft text and documents of the fifth session, dated August 2026.

 

Also Read:

Only 25% of Identified Taxpayers Have Implemented Global Minimum Tax

Global Minimum Tax: Don’t Wait Until Year-End

DGT Records 5,581 Taxpayers Under Global Minimum Tax Scheme
 

Writer: Ideatax | Editor: Thomas Rizal

Previous